Wednesday, 12 February 2025
25.4 C
Singapore
23 C
Thailand
20.6 C
Indonesia
26.1 C
Philippines

18 states challenge SEC over crypto regulation enforcement

18 US states filed a lawsuit challenging the SECโ€™s authority over crypto regulation, seeking state-level control. The legal battle could reshape oversight.

A lawsuit filed by 18 US states is challenging the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The states accuse the agency of attempting to overreach its authority in regulating cryptocurrencies and argue that they, not the SEC, should be responsible for managing cryptocurrency regulations. The DeFi Education Fund, a lobbying group focusing on decentralised finance, joins the lawsuit as a plaintiff.

States seek control over crypto regulation

The lawsuit alleges that the SEC attempts to โ€œunilaterally wrest regulatory authority away from the Statesโ€ by enforcing federal oversight of digital assets. The states aim to halt the SECโ€™s enforcement actions and establish frameworks for managing cryptocurrency markets. This legal move signals a growing frustration among state leaders over federal intervention in the rapidly evolving crypto space.

Key figures in the lawsuit include SEC Chair Gary Gensler, whose handling of cryptocurrency regulation has drawn sharp criticism from the industry and political figures, including Republican president-elect Donald Trump. Genslerโ€™s tenure at the SEC has been marked by aggressive enforcement measures against crypto companies, earning him a polarising reputation.

For years, the regulatory tug-of-war over cryptocurrencies has primarily involved the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the latter often preferred by the crypto industry. However, this new lawsuit led by Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman introduces a fresh dynamic, with states collectively stepping into the fray to assert their role in shaping crypto policies.

Under Genslerโ€™s leadership, the SEC has secured several victories in its campaign against the crypto industry. Federal courts have repeatedly upheld the SECโ€™s authority to regulate digital assets under existing securities laws. However, the lawsuit from the 18 states disputes this interpretation, claiming, โ€œThe SECโ€™s sweeping assertion of regulatory jurisdiction is untenable. The digital assets implicated here are assets, not investment contracts covered by federal securities laws.โ€

This legal battle comes amidst broader industry challenges, including the SECโ€™s high-profile lawsuit against Coinbase, a major cryptocurrency exchange. Coinbase has argued that its platform does not involve trading securities and sought to have the case dismissed. US District Judge Katherine Polk Failla ruled against Coinbase, stating that the transactions at issue align with long-standing legal definitions of securities.

The lawsuitโ€™s invocation of the major questions doctrine adds to the complexity. This legal principle suggests that regulatory actions with significant economic or political implications should have explicit Congressional approval. The states argue that the SECโ€™s actions against the crypto industry require such authorisation. However, courts have dismissed similar arguments in recent cases involving Terraform Labs and Coinbase, suggesting that this line of reasoning may face significant hurdles.

The road ahead

As the debate over cryptocurrency regulation continues, this lawsuit highlights the tensions between state and federal authorities in the US. With states now actively challenging the SECโ€™s jurisdiction, the case could set a pivotal precedent for how digital assets are governed. The crypto industry remains caught in the crossfire of an intensifying regulatory battle.

Hot this week

How Meta’s content moderation shift is redefining social media

Metaโ€™s decision to relax its content moderation policies is reshaping social media, balancing free speech and user safety. This shift impacts users, advertisers, and the future of digital communication.

Aetherdrift brings high-speed action to Magic: The Gathering fans

MTG's Aetherdrift brings high-speed action, new mechanics, and exclusive collectibles in an epic multiverse race starting 7 February.

Sid Meier’s Civilization VII launches worldwide, bringing strategy gaming to new heights

Sid Meierโ€™s Civilization VII launches globally on consoles and PC, promising an expansive strategy experience with new features and multiplayer options.

Lyft introduces AI-powered customer support with Claude

Lyft has partnered with Anthropic to use Claude AI for customer service, cutting response times by 87%. The move raises concerns among drivers.

Insta360 unveils Flow 2 Pro gimbal with AI-powered tracking

Insta360 launches the Flow 2 Pro, an upgraded gimbal with AI-powered tracking, Apple DockKit integration, and new creative shooting modes.