Tuesday, 18 March 2025
29.2 C
Singapore
33.7 C
Thailand
25.6 C
Indonesia
28 C
Philippines

Judge rules in favour of Thomson Reuters in AI copyright battle

On February 6, US District Court Judge Stephanos Bibas ruled in favour of Thomson Reuters in its copyright infringement case against Ross Intelligence, an AI-driven legal research startup. Initially filed in 2020, the lawsuit is one of the first major legal battles concerning the use of copyrighted material in AI training. This ruling could set […]

On February 6, US District Court Judge Stephanos Bibas ruled in favour of Thomson Reuters in its copyright infringement case against Ross Intelligence, an AI-driven legal research startup. Initially filed in 2020, the lawsuit is one of the first major legal battles concerning the use of copyrighted material in AI training. This ruling could set a precedent for similar cases involving AI companies that use copyrighted data without permission.

Other major lawsuits against AI companies like OpenAI and Microsoft are also underway. These cases raise important legal questions about whether AI tools can claim โ€œfair useโ€ when training their models on copyrighted material. The outcome of these lawsuits could shape the future of AI development and copyright laws.

Court finds Ross Intelligence copied Westlaw content

Thomson Reuters, the parent company of the legal research platform Westlaw, argued that Ross Intelligence unlawfully used its proprietary content. Westlaw provides legal professionals access to case law, statutes, and regulations. Still, it includes unique editorial content such as headnotes and summaries of legal principles written by human editors. These headnotes are a key feature of Westlawโ€™s expensive subscription service.

In an attempt to develop its own AI-driven legal search engine, Ross Intelligence allegedly used Westlawโ€™s content without permission. Court documents reveal that after Thomson Reuters declined to license its material to Ross, the startup turned to a third-party company, LegalEase, which provided 25,000 Bulk Memos. These memos contained legal questions and answers based on Westlawโ€™s copyrighted headnotes and were used to train Rossโ€™s AI model.

Judge Bibas dismissed Rossโ€™s fair-use defence, stating that none of its arguments were legally valid. He emphasised how Rossโ€™s use of Westlaw content harmed the market for the original work, as it created a direct competitor. The judge also pointed out that Ross transformed Westlawโ€™s editorial content into numerical data for its AI model, making it a clear case of copyright infringement.

Ross Intelligence ceased operations in 2021, citing financial difficulties caused by the lawsuit. The company had previously called the lawsuit โ€œspuriousโ€ and argued that its AI tool merely โ€œadded noiseโ€ rather than directly copying Westlawโ€™s content. However, the court found overwhelming evidence of direct copying.

Judge Bibas highlighted a specific comparison of 2,830 Bulk Memo questions, Westlaw headnotes, and judicial opinions, which showed undeniable similarities. He concluded the evidence was so clear that no reasonable jury could rule in Rossโ€™s favour.

Thomson Reuters welcomed the decision, with company spokesperson Jeff McCoy stating, โ€œWe are pleased that the court granted summary judgment in our favour and concluded that Westlawโ€™s editorial content, created and maintained by our attorney editors, is protected by copyright and cannot be used without our consent. The copying of our content was not โ€˜fair use.โ€™โ€

While this ruling marks a significant victory for Thomson Reuters, the broader debate over AI and copyright law is far from over. As AI tools evolve, legal battles over data usage and fair use will likely shape the industryโ€™s future.

Hot this week

Katamari Damacy makes a comeback on Apple Arcade this April

Katamari Damacy Rolling LIVE lands on Apple Arcade on April 3, bringing a modern twist to its classic gameplay alongside other nostalgic favourites.

Apple may add live translation to AirPods with iOS 19 update

Apple could add live translation to AirPods with iOS 19, simplifying real-time conversations in other languages. Find out more about this update.

The Vision Pro Metallica concert video is Appleโ€™s most immersive experience yet

Appleโ€™s Vision Pro Metallica concert video delivers an electrifying, immersive experience, setting a new standard for concert films.

More Singapore organisations turning to AI to tackle cyber threats

More Singaporean organisations are using AI for cybersecurity as phishing threats grow, but investment in essential security training is declining.

Meta and Singapore government launch AI incubator to boost innovation

Meta has partnered with the Singapore Government to launch...

Nominations open for 4th edition of Singapore 100 Women in Tech Awards

Nominations for the 4th Singapore 100 Women in Tech Awards are open, celebrating women in tech. Submit nominations by 30 April 2025.

IT leaders accelerate AI PC adoption despite security and infrastructure concerns

A new AMD and IDC survey reveals that 82% of IT leaders plan to adopt AI PCs by year-end, despite security and infrastructure concerns.

Samsung to launch Galaxy A56 5G and Galaxy A36 5G in Singapore on 28 March

Samsung will launch the Galaxy A56 5G and A36 5G in Singapore on 28 March 2025, featuring AI tools, upgraded cameras, and exclusive launch promotions.

Airwallex partners with Discover Global Network to expand payment options

Airwallex partners with Discover Global Network, allowing merchants to accept Discover and Diners Club International cards, reaching 345 million cardholders.

Related Articles