Tuesday, 8 July 2025
28 C
Singapore
29.7 C
Thailand
22.1 C
Indonesia
28.4 C
Philippines

Mark Zuckerberg draws parallels between Meta’s AI practices and YouTube’s copyright policies

Mark Zuckerberg compares Meta’s AI copyright approach to YouTube’s handling of pirated content amidst ongoing legal battles over AI training datasets.

Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg has drawn parallels between YouTube’s efforts to combat pirated content and his own company’s use of a controversial dataset, according to newly released excerpts from a deposition. The deposition is part of the ongoing copyright case Kadrey v. Meta, just one of several legal battles pitting artificial intelligence companies against authors and intellectual property (IP) holders.

Zuckerberg’s statements suggest that Meta’s use of copyrighted material in training its AI models may fall under “fair use.” This argument has been a common defence among AI firms, but many copyright holders disagree.

During his deposition, Zuckerberg pointed to YouTube’s handling of pirated content as a comparison. “YouTube… may end up hosting some stuff that people pirate for some period of time, but YouTube is trying to take that stuff down,” he explained, according to portions of the transcript released this week.

He added that the majority of YouTube content is legitimate and properly licensed. Zuckerberg seems to have used this analogy to frame Meta’s position on using LibGen, a dataset of copyrighted e-books, to train its AI models, specifically its Llama series.

LibGen, often described as a “links aggregator,” has faced multiple lawsuits, shutdown orders, and fines for enabling access to copyrighted works. Meta employees allegedly flagged concerns about the dataset, describing it as “pirated” and warning that its use could damage Meta’s reputation with regulators.

Zuckerberg, however, distanced himself from detailed knowledge of LibGen, stating, “I haven’t heard of that specific thing.” Still, he cautioned against outright bans on datasets that may contain copyrighted material, likening it to banning YouTube due to some pirated content.

This week, the case took another turn, with plaintiffs’ lawyers amending their complaint to include fresh allegations against Meta. These claims suggest Meta cross-referenced LibGen’s pirated books with copyrighted works available for licensing. This strategy allegedly allowed the company to decide whether to pursue agreements with publishers.

The filing also claims Meta used LibGen to train its latest Llama 3 models and is planning to use it to develop Llama 4. Additionally, Meta-researchers allegedly attempted to obscure the use of copyrighted materials during Llama’s training by adding “supervised samples” to its fine-tuning process.

The allegations extend to another dataset sourced from Z-Library, another platform that has faced significant legal challenges for copyright infringement. The amended complaint states that Meta downloaded pirated e-books from Z-Library for training as recently as April 2024.

Meta is not alone in facing scrutiny over the use of copyrighted material in AI training. The tech industry is navigating uncharted legal waters, with courts yet to establish a clear precedent for what constitutes “fair use” in AI development.

Zuckerberg acknowledged the need for caution, stating Meta should avoid using datasets from sources “intentionally trying to violate people’s rights.” However, the claims in the amended complaint, if proven, could complicate Meta’s defence.

The outcome of Kadrey v. Meta could set an important legal benchmark for how copyrighted content is handled in AI training. The tech giant remains under intense scrutiny as the case progresses in the Northern District of California.

Hot this week

Exabeam introduces AI strategy agent to empower cybersecurity leaders

Exabeam Nova adds AI strategy agent to help CISOs plan, justify investments, and improve security posture through board-ready insights.

Mainland investment boom lifts Hong Kong’s market

Chinese firms turn to Hong Kong listings after mainland investors spend US$93B on stocks, eyeing global growth and fresh funding sources.

Resident Evil expands to mobile with new strategy game ‘Survival Unit’

Resident Evil goes mobile with Survival Unit, a new strategy game for iOS and Android set to be revealed on July 10.

Stop Killing Games hits 1.2 million signatures, but challenges remain

The Stop Killing Games petition passed 1.2M signatures, but fake entries and industry pushback may slow its path to EU law.

Sony halts Xperia 1 VII sales in several Asian markets due to technical issues

Sony halts Xperia 1 VII sales in several Asian countries after users report shutdown issues, although it remains available in Singapore for now.

Huawei defends AI model amid claims of using third-party code

Huawei denies using third-party models to train its latest AI, despite claims from a whistleblower and rising competition in China's tech sector.

AI will make cyber defence harder unless you think like a hacker

Cyber experts warn that AI is making cyber attacks smarter, urging firms to adopt a hacker mindset and prepare through simulations.

Persona 5: The Phantom X finally arrives in Southeast Asia

Persona 5: The Phantom X launches in Southeast Asia with a fresh story, fan-favourite characters, and a special event running until July 31.

TikTok may dodge US ban with new app and ownership deal

TikTok could avoid a US ban with the launch of a new app on September 5 and a possible sale to non-Chinese investors, including Oracle.

Related Articles

Popular Categories